Apartments and Airbnb in Fire Island

Fire Island combines soft sand, boardwalks, and wildlife preserves in a setting that slows time. Travelers can stroll wooden paths, bike through quiet towns, or sunbathe on uncrowded shores. The island culture favors flip-flops, fresh seafood, and summer serenity. Visitors experience nature, community, and rest in balance.

Top areas to stay at in Fire Island

Ocean Beach

The social heart of the island, Ocean Beach offers restaurants, shops, and a lively boardwalk scene. Airbnbs in Fire Island’s Ocean Beach area include beach cottages, family homes, and charming bungalows near the bay. Visitors can walk to markets, cafés, and nightlife without vehicles. The area mixes community energy with seaside access.

Cherry Grove

A historic LGBTQ+ destination, Cherry Grove is famous for its artistic expression, cabarets, and inclusive atmosphere. Vacation rentals in Fire Island’s Cherry Grove include waterfront houses, private studios, and stylish summer homes. Guests can enjoy theater nights, art shows, and coastal paths. The neighborhood celebrates freedom and identity.

Saltaire

A quieter and residential village, Saltaire features tennis courts, tree-shaded lanes, and kid-friendly beaches. Rentals in Fire Island’s Saltaire area include traditional cottages, updated beach homes, and well-appointed porches. The area appeals to families and those seeking peace. Saltaire brings suburban comfort to the coast.

Davis Park

Accessible from Patchogue, this eastern community blends a marina lifestyle with scenic trails and natural dunes. Vacation homes in Fire Island’s Davis Park include waterfront decks, dune retreats, and open-layout rentals. Guests enjoy beach bars, sunset strolls, and fishing from piers. Davis Park caters to relaxed, outdoor-focused travelers.

Kismet

Located on the western side of the island, Kismet is known for beach parties, bars, and group-friendly accommodations. Airbnbs in Fire Island’s Kismet neighborhood include spacious homes, duplexes, and deck-laden retreats. Visitors can gather with friends, dine alfresco, and dance by the water. Kismet offers a social and spirited vibe.

What to do if you spend a vacation in Fire Island

Fire Island Lighthouse

This iconic structure near Robert Moses State Park provides sweeping views of the coast and maritime history. Visitors can climb to the top, tour exhibits, and enjoy photo-worthy moments. The surrounding beach and trails offer additional exploration. The lighthouse anchors the island’s visual identity.

Sunken Forest

A rare maritime holly forest nestled between dunes, this site features boardwalk paths and guided nature tours. Guests can spot birds, deer, and unique flora along the shaded route. The preserve supports biodiversity and peaceful walks. The forest adds ecological wonder to a beach vacation.

Sailors Haven

Part of the Fire Island National Seashore, Sailors Haven includes visitor centers, picnic areas, and pristine swimming spots. Travelers can dock boats, walk nature trails, or explore educational programs. The spot blends recreation with learning. Sailors Haven provides variety for families and groups.

Watch Hill

On the island’s southern edge, Watch Hill features campgrounds, a marina, and access to Otis Pike Wilderness. Vacationers can hike protected dunes, paddleboard, or stargaze from sandy clearings. The experience favors adventurers and solitude seekers. Watch Hill expands the island’s wild side.

Cherry’s on the Bay

A beloved bar and performance venue in Cherry Grove, Cherry’s hosts themed nights, drag shows, and bayfront fun. Guests can sip cocktails, meet locals, and dance at sunset. The establishment supports the neighborhood’s inclusive, festive spirit. Cherry’s adds nightlife flair to Fire Island.

Atlantique Beach

A central beach destination, Atlantique includes boat slips, lifeguards, and community events. Families can swim safely, grill meals, or attend movie nights under the stars. The beach suits both day-trippers and long-term guests. Atlantique reflects Fire Island’s coastal lifestyle.

Bellport Ferry Rides

Travelers can reach Fire Island via ferry routes from Bellport, Sayville, and other mainland towns. The journey offers water views, breezes, and anticipation of arrival. Ferries support the island’s rhythm and charm. The ride begins the experience in motion.

Ocean Bay Park Boardwalk

This friendly boardwalk connects cafés, bars, and rental cottages in a mellow, sociable atmosphere. Guests can walk barefoot to beach bars or join bonfires with neighbors. The vibe mixes leisure with community connection. The boardwalk invites slow exploration and shared memories.

Where to find a vacation rental near Fire Island, New York

Montauk, New York

Roughly two and a half hours east of Fire Island, Montauk is a coastal destination known for its iconic lighthouse and sprawling state parks. This end-of-the-island retreat boasts unspoiled beaches, excellent fishing spots, and hiking trails at Shadmoor State Park. Travelers can enjoy the views while staying in a vacation rental in Montauk just minutes from the shore. Montauk’s maritime charm and laid-back luxury offer a perfect escape that balances Fire Island’s breezy ambiance with a rugged Atlantic character.

The Hamptons, New York

Just under two hours from Fire Island, The Hamptons are synonymous with upscale beach living and elegant vacation experiences. Travelers can enjoy art galleries, boutique shopping, and stunning coastline in towns like East Hampton and Southampton. Experience refined beach living from an airbnb in the Hamptons with close proximity to Fire Island’s natural wonders. The area’s refined energy makes it a great complement for travelers seeking variety during their beach retreat.

Shelter Island, New York

Accessible via ferry and located northeast of Fire Island, Shelter Island is a peaceful enclave known for its nature preserves and luxurious seclusion. The Mashomack Preserve offers miles of trails through salt marshes, woodlands, and tidal creeks, perfect for eco-conscious travelers. Stay connected to nature in a house on Shelter Island tucked among quiet forest lanes. Shelter Island’s quiet elegance and commitment to conservation make it an ideal counterpart to Fire Island’s vibrant coastal energy.

Port Jefferson, New York

Approximately two hours northwest, Port Jefferson is a historic harbor town on Long Island’s North Shore. With its scenic marina, lively downtown, and the Bridgeport & Port Jefferson Ferry, this destination blends coastal charm with convenience. Enjoy harbor views and walkable streets from an apartment in Port Jefferson located near shops and cafés. Port Jefferson’s mix of history and relaxed atmosphere complements Fire Island’s beachy spirit while offering a bit more urban accessibility.

Ocean Beach (Mainland), New York

Close to ferry docks and Long Island activities, this mainland area offers convenient stays with beach proximity. Rentals in Ocean Beach (Mainland) include suburban homes and casual lodges. Travelers can relax between trips while based in a suburban home in Ocean Beach near ferry routes. Visitors can relax or plan excursions to the barrier island. The zone supports flexible travel planning.